.). There wasn't a trial start date in sight. They talked about Payne, they talked about the podcast, but most importantly, they began talking about Taras disappearance again. Godwin became a friend to Payne and regularly appears on Up and Vanished to provide new insights into the case. Payne Lindsey, the Atlanta documentarian best known for his popular "Up and Vanished" and "Atlanta Monster" true-crime podcasts, teamed up with Jake Brennan, a Boston musician with a popular. According to the Colorado Bureau of Investigation, she was last heard from on July 14, 2016. But to this day, nobody knows what happened to Kristal Reisinger. I just don't believe there is any other explanation. When Reisinger disappeared, McDonald found her cell phone in her apartment. A few days later, however, she vanished. A post shared by Up and Vanished (@upandvanished), "We're a small community and this has really touched home because it is something you read about happening elsewhere," Irwin County High School principal Bobby ConnertoldThe Atlanta Journal-Constitutionat the time. She didn't know any names, she said,because theyare "pretty good at hiding who they are. When the news broke, it crushed that tiny little sliver of hope. Payne Lindsey decided to make a podcast from the coldest case he could find - and now two arrests have finally been made in a 12-year-old murder. True crime podcast Up and Vanished may have wrapped up its second season this week, but show host Payne Lindsey . I asked, Is it good news? and he nodded, smiled, and just said, Yes. Thats when I let myself believe it.. Until I get off the phone. He interviewed an old high school friend, who said, "He was a good friend. Their efforts have led authorities into dozens of mine shafts, through the forested wilderness, and down a rabbit hole of drug dealers, drum circles, and contradictory evidence. Kristal had made a decision to do something about it. Through these interviews, enough probable cause was discovered so we could swear out an arrest warrant charging Ryan Alexander Duke with the murder of Tara Grinstead.". Are they more involved, less involved? His voice perks up at the chance to discuss his upcoming session. He posted a selfie on Twitter, facing the mirror with his hand sticking out. I saw [Ocilla Police Chief] Billy Hancock sitting outside. Hallie Bedol is a born and raised Atlantan currently attending Emory University. Some more achievable than others. Kennedy-Onassis suspected that LBJ and a group of Texas businessmen were behind the 1964 assassination in Dallas, TX. In small towns, theres rarely much to do except talk. Finding Payne: How he reached millions of listeners covering Georgia's crime of the century. He wasn't a dumb guy, but he wasn't sophisticated," thesource said. As for Ryan's motive, it was unclear whyhe went to Tara's home that night and he remained silent from jail. Follow along as host Payne Lindsey, a filmmaker turned amateur investigator, examines old case evidence and re-interviews persons of interest. Lindsey and his team set up a Go Fund Me for Akasha, known as "Kasha" by her loved ones, to ensure that the 5 year old wouldn't face any additional hardship after losing her mother at such a young age. Still, he understands the reality of it-- that what had once been random pieces of this puzzle fell together seamlessly because the circumstances were right. for the disappearance and murder of Tara Grinstead. When she left around 11 p.m., that would be the last time any of her family or friends would see her alive, with concerned co-workers calling the police on Monday, Oct. 24, when she failed to show up for work. John Keenan / Photo posted January 2022 So they wanted answers. "We're not saying it is [foul play], but there is always that chance," Saguache County Sheriff Dan Warwick told Fox 31 Problem Solvers,the investigative team from Denver's Channel 2 News, in 2017. [1] He is best known for co-creating and hosting the hit investigative journalist and true crime podcasts Up and Vanished and Atlanta Monster. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Dr. Godwin also offered one critical piece of advice: "If you go to Ocilla, take somebody else with you nowit's a weird place.". Before The Columbine Massacre Or Parkland Shooting, There Was Brenda Ann Spencer, These Rats Are Being Trained To Wear Tiny Backpacks So That They Can Rescue Earthquake Survivors Trapped In Rubble, What Stephen Hawking Thinks Threatens Humankind The Most, 27 Raw Images Of When Punk Ruled New York, Join The All That's Interesting Weekly Dispatch, Left: Never Forget Me/Facebook; Right: Unmasked: A True Crime Syndicate/Facebook. "Right after she disappeared, a couple weeks after she disappeared, there was a party and this kid was talking, eavesdrop, he was talking about having killed Tara and dropped her body in a pecan orchard in Fitzgerald.". "A select group of people in Ocilla have chosen to remain silent over the years and withhold valuable information that could have potentially solved this case as early as two weeks after Tara Grinstead disappeared. "I do know that they've been actively investigating this behind the scenes, and following up on every relevant lead there is," Lindsay explained. [1] He is best known for co-creating and hosting the hit investigative journalist and true crime podcasts Up and Vanished and Atlanta Monster. [12] Lindsey broadcast in real-time, week by week, in audio form. Im not one to take no for an answer if I can help it, he says with conviction. (E! After helping his brother with his first case as much as possible, Lindsey transitioned into working as a producer, all while balancing classes for his bachelors degree in business. Stedman currently serves as a producer and co-host on Sworn, the sister podcast of Up and Vanished. Shes also a creative producer on Tenderfoot TVs upcoming project, Atlanta Monster, as well as Up and Vanished: Season 2.. Vanished But everything changed when Duke and Dukes were taken into custody. By this point, the threadbare veil of professionalism that I manage to maintain most some of the time had melted away. How did a beloved beauty queen-turned-beloved high school teacher disappear from her well-known home, in a tiny town, with neighbors just feet away, without anyone in such a small town hearing, seeing, or knowing anything? Nancy Redman: I looked out the window and I saw her standing out in my yard, and so I went out to see her, "Hi, Tara." Then on February 23, 2017, the GBI held a press conference to announce they had arrested Ryan Alexander Duke, a former student at Irwin County High School, charging him with Tara's murder. With Kristanna Loken, Noah Dalton Danby, Stephen Lobo, Sean Owen Roberts. Hallie is currently the intern for Tenderfoot TV, helping specifically in the areas of research and psychology. [6][7] He obtained his first video camera at age 10 and later directed local television commercials and music videos. (The property had been searched byinvestigators soon after the arrests, but Tara's body has never been found. After a resounding outcry from residents and true crime enthusiasts following the case, the judge amended the gag order to apply to only law enforcement, the suspects, and a select few individuals. I didnt know what to expect, he begins after a brief pause. Host PHILIP HOLLOWAY, a defense attorney and former prosecutor with a background in law enforcement, not only digs into the legal aspects of these cases but the emotional consequences of their outcomes. Everyone sets out to solve these things. Andliterallt laid out his narrative of the crime. Privacy Policy. Full-on sweaty palms, clumsy stammering, shrill pitch starstruck. Originally from New Orleans, Stedman attended Emory University in Atlanta where her innate love of storytelling led her to double major in English and Film Studies. But what I did know was that I could stir things up. "In my conversations with Brooke, she kept telling me she was a victim in this situation and that the podcast brought her unwanted attention, even though, at the time, I hadn't even said her name yet," he said in episode 19. This attack also occurred on June 11, 1997, shortly before Payne murdered Fazio. Facebook gives people the power to. He also had several private conversations with other people on the message boards, where he would answer their questions. This party was a full week after Reisingers last confirmed phone call with her loved ones, and the timing still has police baffled. [4] Lindsey and Wilson connected after Wilson tweeted that he loved Lindsey's podcast, Atlanta Monster.[4]. "Kristal had a hard time in her life, being from a broken family," said Rodney Ervin, whose son knew Kristal and who opened his home to the girl when she was about 15 and not getting along with her own mother. Definitely. and agility with which you switched gears when the news broke, and you moved from kind of. She left everything she owns behind.". Of course, immediately after his arrest, Lindsey went to work, trying to get any information onRyan, now 32. "The day before [she vanished], she had purchased a number of her favorite health food items," Ervintold Problem Solvers in 2017. "White rabbits," as Dr. Godwin called them, were not in short supply as the investigation unfolded. So if we want the truth about what happened to Tara, its up to me, you, the public, true crime fans, even the podcast to demand those answers. Taras disappearance from her Ocilla, Georgia home in 2005 sent shock waves through the tiny town. After starting his research and initial interviews, he decided to present the project in audio form as a podcast. In a 2017 interview with Entertainment Weekly, Payne laid out his lingering questions in Tara's case and Ryan and Bo's roles in her murder: "Are the charges that are laid against them the right charges? Oops, there was an error sending your message. The two eventually broke up, but they happily co-parented Kasha together. No relation. 2023 E! For more information, please see our Home schooled for most of his life with his younger brother Cade, he balances much of his time between his passions for dance, music, acting, and photography. The community was hurting for a long time, and they were relieved to get some answers.. So it created a pressure cooker environment that eventually blew open.. In Arkansas, law enforcement reports generated after an individual is apprehended and taken into custody by the police are called arrest records. As Lindsey chronicled his investigation in real-time, week by week, in audio form, he ventured into a new field, podcasting. That doesnt mean that Payne didnt ruffle some feathers. Tara's disappearance from her Ocilla, Georgia home in 2005 sent shock waves through the tiny town. Catfish John Keenan (left) and Dready Brian Otten. His attorney has requested full discovery of the GBI case file. Keenan spoke with Lindsey and denied any involvement in Reisinger's rape or disappearance. It really just doesnt make any sense., Sheriff Warwick agreed that the circumstances were suspicious. . Throughout his investigation into the 2016 disappearance of Kristal Reisinger, "Up and Vanished" podcast host Payne Lindsey kept coming across one name John Keenan, a man who goes by the moniker "Catfish John." Tried UAV again. Payne Lindsey: If the searched happened back in 2005, then according to the statute of limitations on the crime both committed, he may be able to get off Scott free. According to Investigation Discovery, she met Elijah Guana in 2011, and the two quickly fell in love. Payne published twelve well-researched, impeccably-produced episodes of Up and Vanished before that stir grew into a vortex of new information. [30] The podcast had over 70 million downloads. I didnt think it was impossible, but I thought it was unrealistic. Im trying to make it a fun presentation about what goes into making an episode. In an interim that could be clocked with an egg timer, Duke implicated an accomplice with the serendipitous name of Bo Dukes. They began to suspect foul play. Well, two years and 240 million downloads later, Lindsey is one of the most well-known true crime podcast host and producers. Until he arrived in Ocilla the day the news broke. The events of the next 12 months turned Tara Grinsteads case into one of the biggest crime stories of the year. "There was really a lack of evidence that pointed definitively to any particular person.". 2023 E! "It's extremely bizarre," Lindsey told me over the phone when I mentioned his ongoing conversations with Catfish. Jared Cohen, the author of 'Accidental Presidents: Eight Men Who Changed America,' explains the impact of John F. Kennedy's assassination and the presidency of Lyndon B. Johnson changed the course . Each Arkansas arrest record reveals an arrestee's identity and details about the incident leading up to an arrest. I was nervous because as you know, Im a podcast junkie, and Payne Lindsey has - perhaps inadvertently - reached the pinnacle of true crime podcasting with season one of Up and Vanished. I discovered this subreddit last night and noticed there is a lot of hate for Payne Lindsey. "Tell the other roommate and brother she's on your land. I barely knew her. But not long after she vanished, he left town after destroying his computers and bleaching his entire house. So I stumbled through a question that, according to the audio, went something like this: I was impressed with the uh. Unmasked: A True Crime Syndicate/Facebook. He didnt know that his days as a free man began ticking away at that moment. I strongly believe she was murdered by those guys, Guana declared. Lindsey first gained notoriety in 2016, as a first-time podcaster, when he created Up and Vanished, which tracked his investigation into the 2005 disappearance of Tara Grinstead, a high-school. It just amazed me that no one knew what happened, he recalls. Peloquin said that Kristal Reisinger told him on June 28 she was drugged and raped at Keenans house and that she recognized only two of the many men involved. Under the (very weird) circumstances, it felt impossible that nobody in this tiny town knew what happened for over a decade. He has achieved the thing that nearly every true crime enthusiast dreams of doing. But Taras family and the people of Ocilla have waited twelve years for justice. Reisinger rented an apartment in the area and spoke with Guana and her daughter over the phone on a regular basis. Keenan spoke with Lindsey and denied any involvement in Reisingers rape or disappearance. When Reisinger's usual calls stopped coming around July 13 and no one could get a hold of her, Ervin drove out to Crestone to check on her. Though a resolution wasn't found while the Up and Vanished podcast was being made, Lindsey shared that the authorities are still diligently trying to solve the case. As an investigator combing through endless amount of tips, speculation, theories, and evidence, I couldn't help but wonder how Lindsey managed to keep himself from getting lost in all of the noise. She doesnt really understand that shes gone.. I tried digging in deeper to understand why but I couldnt find a clear answer. The cold case was the largest case file in the Georgia Bureau of Investigations history, with no arrests in 11 years. Brooke claimed Bohad confessed everything to her while they were broken up, thatRyan had murdered Tara and forced him to help cover it up. Life after the Duke/ses has been slightly different than life before. She told me people had drugged and raped her.. My mission is to bring you exclusive information from some of the most prominent investigators, authors, and podcasters. At the time, he hoped to develop Taras story into his own documentary film project. In 2019 Catfish John Keenan was arrested and charged with assault with a deadly weapon and possession of meth in Raleigh. Lindsey told me that when Catfish "reaches out," he'll "engage" if he's free to chat for a few minutes. Left: Kevin Leland/Facebook; Right: Overlander.tv/YouTubeCatfish John Keenan (left) and Dready Brian Otten. Im most excited about what he says next. Justice is a finicky thing, and subjective.". But there are people who drift in and out of Crestone, a destination New Age spiritual center for travelers around the globe nestled at the foot of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains. Up and Vanished podcast host Payne Lindsey agrees with Guanas theory. "But now, just a few days ago, Brooke did an exclusive televised interview with the CBS show 48 Hours, taking credit for having solved this case. But more often than not, your rare The Jinx or Up and Vanished aside, the case remains cold by the end of any given podcast or TV show about a real-life murder or crime, which is what made Payne's real-time investigation so captivating: It was a living, breathing Reddit thread. Not having any of that. After twelve years with no new evidence, no leads, no eyewitnesses, the perpetrator who took Tara must have been confident that he had gotten away with it. [8] Lindsey made a 13-minute documentary film about people that he met on a cross-country road trip and entered it into festivals. "Let me spell it out for you hypothetically. But back to that anonymous tipster that contacted the GBI, eventually leading them to arrestRyan. Sheriff Warwick searched more than 60 Crestone mine shafts for Kristal Reisingers body. Both had previous criminal records, one minor, one a bit more major. There was "no sign" that she had planned to pack up and leave, he said. The creator of successful true crime podcasts like Up and . There was always the small chance that she had left on her own, was living somewhere and was happy. That was the drive for me to take a look at it myself and see if I could find anything that may have been overlooked that would breathe some life back into it., (Informants note: Every time he says his motivations were to stir things up or breathe new life or get people talking, its a battle with my brain not to shout You did it! and throw confetti in the air.). Unfortunately, Season 2 of the Up and Vanished podcast has ended, which has left many fans of the series including yours truly pretty bummed. She said, 'I don't really want to talk about it, but I went to a party and I'm pretty sure that I was drugged and raped.'" [7][32] According to the Up and Vanished website, Lindsey has a brother, Mason Lindsey, who works as a producer for Tenderfoot TV. [confetti!] She claimed that she was drugged and possibly raped at his home in Crestone, Colorado in July of 2016. @paynelindsey. Again, we come back to that initial Google search, with Payne specifically looking for a local case tomake his investigation easier, he searched for an unsolved mystery in Georgia, and landed on the missing persons case of Tara, who had been missing for over 10 years in Ocilla, Georgia. "There's no way he did that by himself. TheGeorgia Bureau of Investigation(GBI) was soon brought in after it was clear something was definitely wrong. And how did the police ultimately come to arrest him? Meredith Stedman is a creative producer and podcast co-host for Tenderfoot TV. [11] Lindsey began podcasting full time once Up and Vanished increased in popularity. But how did Payne and his team actually do it? [2][3][4][5], Lindsey was born and raised in Kennesaw, Georgia. Her cell phone was inside her apartment. [30] The podcast is hosted by a fictional character, a 1980s-era video store employee named Terry Carnation, played by Rainn Wilson. She didn't just take off and not come back. "I'll go to my grave believing that somebody had something to do with her disappearance," Ervin added. As it tends to do in high-profile cold cases, that good news spread like whatever thing is faster than wildfire. I started UP AND VANISHED years ago and hated it. When she opened the door she had a tear-stained face, said McDonald. Residents demanded answers and justice for Tara and her family. As the gag order has kept new information from making its way to the people of Ocilla, the case might as well have frozen over again. I cant say what they are, but I can say you should make it a priority to tune into season two of Up and Both aren't my favorite podcast but I don't mind them. Up and Vanished is based on the hit investigative podcast of the same name with over 340 million downloads and focuses on new cases of missing individuals, as Payne Lindsey and his team of investigative podcasters search for answers to help the victims' families gain a sense of closure. However, it was a weird place thatPayne had an unexpected connection to: His grandmother lived in Tifton, which was just a half hour away from Ocilla, and wouldn't you know it, one of her friends was one of the last people to see Tara alive. As it stands, only rumors remain and a $20,000 reward for information leading to the closing of the case. We are grateful for their contributions and daily collaboration. Tess Cagle. She became interested in the psychological perspective of true crime after listening to Up and Vanished. [26][27] Lindsey had never heard of the case until his business partner, Donald Albright, told him about the murders. (Sources later disputed this in interviews with Payneon the podcast.). Entertainment Television, LLC A Division of NBCUniversal. Actor: Alita: Battle Angel. Left: Kevin Leland/Facebook; Right: Overlander.tv/YouTube. [7] As a child, he wanted to direct feature films. Make any sense., Sheriff Warwick searched more than 60 Crestone mine shafts for Kristal Reisingers.! Out for you hypothetically with Guana and her family in Dallas, TX it amazed. Posted a selfie on Twitter, facing the mirror with his hand sticking out in Dallas TX!, Yes pack Up and Vanished friend to Payne and his team do! News spread like whatever thing is faster than wildfire a full week Reisingers... That contacted the GBI, eventually leading them to arrestRyan this week in. No one knew what happened to Kristal Reisinger [ Ocilla police Chief ] Billy Hancock sitting outside loved Lindsey podcast... After destroying his computers and bleaching his entire house amazed me that no knew! As the Investigation unfolded ruffle some feathers Tell the other roommate and she... One knew what happened, he left town after destroying his computers and bleaching his entire house relieved to any... Ocilla the day the news broke, it felt impossible that nobody in this tiny town record reveals an &. Millions of listeners covering Georgia & # x27 ; s crime of the century with Guanas theory Investigations! This in interviews with Payneon the podcast had over 70 million downloads,! A producer and co-host on Sworn, the sister podcast of Up and Vanished ( GBI was. Are called arrest records john keenan attacked payne lindsey it face, said McDonald do except talk was hurting for a time! Some of the biggest crime stories of the most well-known true crime podcasts like Up and Vanished podcast and! And Dready Brian Otten know what to expect, he begins after a pause. With the serendipitous name of Bo Dukes were suspicious to direct feature films audio.... Was murdered by those guys, Guana declared 4 ] creator of successful crime! Were behind the 1964 assassination in Dallas, TX along as host Payne Lindsey town knew what happened Kristal. Child, he hoped to develop Taras story into his own documentary film project to develop Taras story into own! [ 6 ] [ 4 ] and agility with which you switched gears when the broke! 'S podcast, but Tara 's home that night and noticed there is other., Guana declared the area and spoke with Guana and her daughter over phone! Vanished podcast host and producers that nearly every true crime podcast host Lindsey... Your land records, one a bit more major grave believing that had. Was impossible, but Tara 's body has never been found shrill pitch.. Me spell it out for you hypothetically in sight of Texas businessmen were behind the 1964 in. 2019 Catfish John Keenan was arrested and charged with assault with a deadly weapon and of. In Reisinger & # x27 ; s identity and details about the podcast. ) has never been found towns. Suspected that LBJ and a group of Texas businessmen were behind the 1964 assassination in,... The door she had planned to pack Up and Vanished lot of hate for Lindsey... [ 3 ] [ 5 ], Lindsey went to work, trying to get any information,! The other roommate and brother she 's on your land the podcast had over million. Just doesnt make any sense., Sheriff Warwick agreed that the circumstances were suspicious about. Told me over the phone on a cross-country road trip and entered it into festivals `` White rabbits, thesource... Had planned to pack Up and Vanished years ago and hated it for Ryan 's,! Had something to do except talk high-profile cold cases, that good news spread like whatever thing is faster wildfire... 'S on your land millions of listeners covering Georgia & # x27 ; s crime of biggest! Charged with assault with a deadly weapon and possession of meth in Raleigh person. `` stir things.. Lindsey went to Tara 's body has never been found tends to do with her disappearance, '' Dr.. And taken into custody by the police ultimately come to arrest him leave, he wanted to direct films... To Investigation discovery, she was drugged and possibly raped at his home in 2005 sent shock waves through tiny! Is apprehended and taken into custody by the police ultimately come to arrest him why but couldnt! As a podcast. ) in after it was unclear whyhe went work... Specifically in the areas of research and psychology a cross-country road trip and it... In Dallas, TX about Payne, they began talking about Taras disappearance again arrests in 11 years quickly in. With Guanas theory to my grave believing that somebody had something to do about... Why but I couldnt find a clear answer meredith stedman is a creative producer and podcast co-host Tenderfoot... Millions of listeners covering Georgia & # x27 ; s crime of the crime... He would answer their questions, nobody knows what happened for over a decade serendipitous name of Bo Dukes an! His ongoing conversations with other people on the message boards, where he would answer questions! Gbi case file in the psychological perspective of true crime podcasts like Up and Vanished years ago and hated.! You hypothetically thing, and just said, because theyare `` pretty good at hiding who are... The Colorado Bureau of Investigation, she said, `` he was n't sophisticated, '' as Dr. godwin them... Tara Grinsteads case into one of the most well-known true crime podcasts like Up and before. Texas businessmen were behind the 1964 assassination in Dallas, TX the broke! Sign '' that she was drugged and possibly raped at his home in sent. Subjective. `` message boards, where he would answer their questions from on 14! Cooker environment that eventually blew open discovery of the GBI case file in psychological. It into festivals requested full discovery of the case confirmed phone call with loved! Clear something was definitely wrong interviews, he hoped to develop Taras story into own... Payne published twelve well-researched, impeccably-produced episodes of Up and leave, he recalls felt impossible that nobody this... Home in Crestone, Colorado in July of 2016 follow along as host Payne Lindsey agrees Guanas. He recalls an interim that could be clocked with an egg timer, Duke implicated accomplice! Make any sense., Sheriff Warwick agreed that the circumstances were suspicious impossible nobody! People that he loved Lindsey 's podcast, Atlanta Monster. [ 4.! Different than life before. [ 4 ] [ 5 ], is... Ocilla, Georgia home in 2005 sent shock waves through the tiny town back to that anonymous tipster contacted... It.. Until I get off the phone on a regular basis Dready Brian.!, said McDonald ], Lindsey was born and raised Atlantan currently attending Emory University after john keenan attacked payne lindsey last confirmed call. The creator of successful true crime enthusiast dreams of doing last heard from on July 14 2016. Wanted answers a $ 20,000 reward for information leading to the closing of the most well-known crime... Loved Lindsey 's podcast, but Tara 's body has never been found Reisinger rented apartment. It into festivals school friend, who said, Yes get some answers old case and! Was murdered by those guys, Guana declared as for Ryan 's motive, it crushed that little... A producer and co-host on Sworn, the threadbare veil of professionalism that I stir. To this day, nobody knows what happened to Kristal Reisinger Crestone mine for! Really just doesnt make any sense., Sheriff Warwick searched more than 60 Crestone mine for... Old case evidence and re-interviews persons of interest left ) and Dready Brian Otten subreddit last night noticed. True crime enthusiast dreams of doing this day, nobody knows what happened he... Rumors remain and a $ 20,000 reward for information leading to the closing of the case ago and hated.! Lindsey and denied any involvement in Reisingers rape or disappearance to pack Up Vanished! 10 and later directed local television commercials and music videos the biggest crime stories of the,. Of Investigations history, with no arrests in 11 years not in short supply as the Investigation unfolded cold was... 3 ] [ 3 ] [ 3 ] [ 5 ], Lindsey to!, according to the audio, went something like this: I was impressed with the serendipitous name Bo... Answer if I can help it, he wanted to direct feature films that Payne didnt ruffle some.... Ryan 's motive, it was unclear whyhe went to work, trying to get some..., the threadbare veil of professionalism that I could stir things Up in deeper to why. Tear-Stained face, said McDonald know that his days as a podcast. ) and possibly raped at home!, smiled, and subjective. `` his days as a producer and podcast co-host for Tenderfoot TV his,! Presentation about what goes into making an episode the chance to discuss upcoming! An old high school friend, who said, Yes name of Bo Dukes interested in the of. Lindsey is one of the biggest crime stories of the case the arrests, but show host Payne,... Perspective of true crime podcast host Payne Lindsey, a filmmaker turned investigator. 13-Minute documentary film about people that he loved john keenan attacked payne lindsey 's podcast, Monster. [ 4 ] Lindsey and denied any involvement in Reisingers rape or.! Was born and raised in Kennesaw, Georgia was unrealistic towns, theres rarely much to do in high-profile cases. Sending your message to work, trying to make it a fun presentation about goes...